Authentic Community Engagement

This post originally appeared in the Vail Daily on 6.15.17, in my regular guest editorial column. I had been thinking a lot about my upcoming transition to Jeffco when I wrote this. I look forward to hearing your perspective on it, and how we translate these ideas into reality.

It can be argued that our nation now stands at a more divided place than possibly any other time in our history, with the exception of the Civil War. Then, the divisions were around region (north versus south), economy (industrial versus agricultural) and morality (debates about the institution of slavery).

Today, we have serious and real divisions present around things such as ideology (conservatism versus liberalism), values (freedom versus equality) and even religion (believers versus non-believers).

In no way diminishing the terrible sacrifices that occurred during the Civil War, in some ways our divisions today are possibly more difficult to reconcile because they are not generally sectioned off into the north and the south. Our divisions are within states, communities, neighborhoods and even within families.

Instead of communities working together on their problems, the conversations quickly descend into fact wars, distortions based on any number of logical fallacies and intentional efforts to portray the other group as a “them” and undermine “their” legitimacy of even being able to engage in the conversation. Snarky sound bites and ad hominem attacks, coupled with an increasing “tuning out,” become the norm.

While one need look no further than the daily circus that is the current state of our national government, the same sorts of behaviors that are all too common in Washington are increasingly present within our communities.

As many of you know, I am leaving the superintendent role with Eagle County Schools to assume that position with Jefferson County Public Schools on July 1. As I’ve worked on my professional transition from our relatively peaceful Eagle River Valley into the more bare-knuckle politics that come with the Front Range, I see a microcosm of the same tensions and behaviors that are fracturing our nation.

One of the main problems is that we have lost our ability to hear one another and acknowledge what Colorado communication researchers Martin Carcasson and Leah Sprain call “competing positive values” — an understanding that there are many difficult community situations where “multiple legitimate values point reasonable people in conflicting directions.”

One possible solution to our dilemma is a process known as “deliberative democracy,” where decisions are reached through the authentic engagement of the community, respectful inclusion of multiple perspectives and consensus building.

Researchers James Fishkin and Robert Luskin identified five core concepts for what deliberative democracy should be:

• Informed: Arguments should be supported by reasonably accurate factual claims.

• Balanced: Arguments should be met by contrary arguments.

• Conscientious: The participants should be willing to talk and listen with civility and respect.

• Substantive: Arguments should be considered sincerely on their merits, not on how they are made or who is making them.

• Comprehensive: All points of view held by significant portions of the population should receive attention.

This kind of intentional and deliberate communication and decision-making is certainly not without its downsides. It moves our form of democracy closer to the direct model (i.e., we are engaged in decisions directly), rather than the representative model (i.e., we elect others to represent us in making decisions). These processes can be time-consuming, contentious and are certainly inefficient compared to more top-down approaches.

However, given the state in which we currently find ourselves, I’d argue this kind of direct engagement is exactly the kind of work we need to be doing — speaking our truths, but also hearing one another.

Sir Winston Churchill said, “Courage is what it takes to stand up and speak. Courage is also what it takes to sit down and listen.”

Indeed.

 

5 thoughts on “Authentic Community Engagement

  1. Well said, Jason…reminds me a bit of the “win-win” method of negotiations…school board and teachers in Concord needed to change the dynamic. A basic mutual interest needed to be established first.
    Deb

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Finally, a thoughtful conversation where generous intention and honesty exist. Thank you and I find the term deliberative democracy very intriguing and look forward to seeing it unfold and be put into action! Welcome to Jeffco.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. We were all born with 2 ears and one mouth. Which means to listen more and talk less. Take it further by adding 2 eyes to see or read more and talk less. My favorite section of the DD (deliberative democracy) is:
    • Conscientious: The participants should be willing to talk and listen with civility and respect.
    Let us all work on that one!
    Thank you Dr. Glass for the insight.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I love this approach, and I think it’s always imperative that we listen and do our best to truly understand all sides. In the case of Jeffco, I would say the source of the strife and division we’ve experienced centers around the very concept of public schools. I’m a product and huge supporter of public schools. I believe strongly in the public and neighborhood school model. I would never say Jeffco Schools are perfect and don’t need improvement – every organization should always seek to improve. But I believe in the model. However, there are those who, to their core, very clearly want to see public schools dismantled and schools privatized, and often those in favor of privatization don’t come right out and call it that – they just relentlessly attack the public school system, refusing to see or acknowledge successes and just focusing on the actual or contrived needs for improvement. The five core concepts for what deliberative democracy should look like are excellent strategies to keep in mind when engaging with those with differing viewpoints. My hope is that your genuine interest and efforts to engage all Jeffco stakeholders will be successful in easing some of the tensions here in Jeffco so we can all move together in the direction in the common goal of doing what’s best for students. I plan to do my part to join you in this effort! Thanks again for your leadership!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Thanks, Tina. I expect to get my hand bitten more than once as I attempt to reach out. Frankly, that’s already happening! However, it is my responsibility to keep building and extending those bridges, no matter how many times they get knocked down. We will keep up the outreach and find those partners from across our community who want to help move our schools and Jeffco forward.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s